Saturday, January 14, 2012

MMA Fan HQ UNOFFICIAL Scoring/Results For "UFC 142: ALDO vs MENDES" Main Card Bouts

We have been trying to promote individual scoring among MMA fans when watching fights. We want fans to put themselves in a judges' position and score fights honestly and unbiased. We want fans to understand the "10-point must" scoring system that is used under the Unified Rules of Combat that are in place to regulate MMA.With many draws, split decisions, and questionable results that quickly gather criticism of judges and the scoring system, we want fans to give honest scores that include 10-10, 10-8, and even 10-7 scores. If we want MMA to be recognized legitimately as a true sport, then we must become true legitimate fans in the process. 




Edson Barboza (9-0-0) vs Terry Etim (15-3-0) (LW)

Rnd1
Rnd2
Rnd3
TOTAL/RESULT
Barboza
10
10
KO
Rnd3 KO (Spinning Heel Kick) at 2:02
Etim
9
9
-
-
Barboza defeats Etim via Rnd3 KO
Official Ruling: Rnd3 KO (Spinning Heel Kick) win for Barboza at 2:02-No scores needed



Erick "Indio" Silva (13-1-0(1)) vs Carlo "Neo" Prater (29-10-1) (WW)


Rnd1
Rnd2
Rnd3
TOTAL/RESULT
Silva
-
-
-
-
Prater
DQ
-
-
Rnd1 Disqualification (Punches to back of head) at 0:29
Prater defeats Silva via Rnd1 Disqualification
Official Ruling: Rnd1 Disqualification (punches to the back of the head) win for Prater at 0:29-No scores needed
Referee Mario Yamasaki called an end to the fight after Silva landed multiple strikes to the back of the head of Prater after he was knocked down and trying to return to his feet. When showing the replay during the post fight interviews, it did appear that strikes did hit the back of Prater's head, as defined by referees and the unified rules with the back of the head being any point past the ears.



Rousimar "Toquinho" Palhares (13-3-0) vs Mike Massenzio (13-5-0) (MW)

Rnd1
Rnd2
Rnd3
TOTAL/RESULT
Palhares
SUB
-
-
Rnd1 Submission (Heel Hook) at 1:03
Massenzio
-
-
-
-
Palhares defeats Masasenzio via Rnd1 Submission
Official Ruling: Rnd1 Submission (Heel Hook) win for Palhares at 1:03-No scores needed


Co-Main Event:
Vitor "The Phenom" Belfort (20-9-0) vs Anthony "Rumble" Johnson (10-3-0) (MW)

Rnd1
Rnd2
Rnd3
TOTAL/RESULT
Belfort
SUB
-
-
Rnd1 Submission (RNC) at 4:49
Johnson
-
-
-
-
Belfort defeats Johnson via Rnd1 Submission
Official Ruling: Rnd1 Submission (Rear Naked Choke) win for Belfort at 4:49-No scores needed
Johnson weighed in 11lbs over the 186lb cutoff limit of the division at the official weigh-ins the day before the fight and was fined 20% of his fight purse, which is forfeited to Belfort. On the day of the fight, Johnson was forced to weigh in again with the stipulation that he did not weigh in more than 205lbs (the cutoff limit for the division above), and weighed in at 204lbs to be allowed to fight.


Main Event/Featherweight (145-136lbs) Championship Bout:
Jose "Scarface" Aldo (20-1-0) vs Chad "Money" Mendes (11-0-0) (FW)

Rnd1
Rnd2
Rnd3
Rnd4
Rnd5
TOTAL/RESULT
(C)Aldo
KO
-
-
-
-
Rnd1 KO (Knee & Punches) at 4:59
Mendes
-
-
-
-
-
-
Aldo defeats Mendes via Rnd1 KO
Official Scoring: Rnd1 KO (Knee & Punches) win for Aldo at 4:59-No scores needed
Aldo retains his title and remains the Undisputed UFC Featherweight champion.


All Brazilian born competitors on the main card (not counting the fact that Silva/Prater was between two Brazilian fighters) earned victories on the main card for this event in their native Brazil on the biggest stage in the sport of MMA.


These are our own "UNOFFICIAL" scores for the main card bouts. We include official scoring & results to compare our scoring to the real deal. We encourage fellow MMA fans to do the same and share their thoughts on judging criteria, how these fights went, how you judged them, and more.

No comments:

Post a Comment